Neanderthal dental tartar uncovers plant-based diet- and drugs
Analysis of teeth of Spanish Neanderthals shows diet of pine nuts, mushrooms and moss and indicates possible self-medication for ache and diarrhoea
A diet of pine nuts, mushrooms and moss might sound like modernist cuisine, but it turns out it was criterion fare for Spanish Neanderthals.
Researchers analyzing the teeth of the heavy-browed hominids have discovered that while Neanderthals in Belgium were chomping on woolly rhinoceros, those farther souths were surviving on plants and may even have use naturally occurring painkillers to ease toothache.
The findings, the researchers tell, are yet another blow to the popular misconception of Neanderthals as brutish simpletons.
Neanderthals , not amazingly, are doing different things, exploiting different things, in different places, said Keith Dobney, a bioarchaeologist and co-author of the research from the University of Liverpool.
Writing in the publication Nature, Dobney and an international squad of colleagues describe how they analysed ancient Dna from microbes and food debris preserved in the dental tartar, or calculus, of three Neanderthals dating from 42,000 to 50,000 years ago. Two of the individuals were from the El Sidrn cave in Spain while one was from the Spy Cave in Belgium.
The results reveal that northern Neanderthals had a wide-ranging diet, with evidence of a mushroom known as gray shag in their tartar, along with tracings of woolly rhinoceros and wild sheep.
By contrast Neanderthals from El Sidrn demonstrated no evidence of meat eating instead they appear to have survived on a mix of forest moss, pine nuts and a mushroom known as split gill.
The difference was further backed up by DN-Abased analysis of the diversity and make-up of microbial communities that had lived in the Neanderthals mouths.
The findings support previous surveys suggesting that the Neanderthals of El Sidrn ate little meat, although Dobney cautioned against describing broader conclusions, citing the small sample size of the latest examine. I hesitate to say that we have clear, definitive proof that Neanderthals in Spain were vegetarian, he said.
Indeed, research looking at marks on the bones of Neanderthals from El Sidrn has suggested they might been the victims of cannibalism. While Dobney does not rule out the potential, he points out that the two Neanderthals in the latest examine are unlikely to have been feasting on their relatives.
You would expect if Neanderthals were feeing one another, that the quantity of Neanderthal DNA would be a lot higher in[ the tartar] it would be part of the food rubble, he said.[ That] doesnt appear to be the case.
One of the Spanish Neanderthals is known to have had a painful dental abscess, while analysis of the tartar from the same individual yielded evidence of a parasite known to cause diarrhoea in humans.
To cope, the researchers add, the unfortunate individual might have been self-medicating. While previous work has suggested the El Sidrn Neanderthals might have exploited yarrow and chamomile, the tartar of the unwell person proves evidence of poplar, which contains the active ingredient of aspirin, salicylic acid, and a species of penicillium fungus, indicating the Neanderthal might have benefited from a natural source of antibiotics.
Potentially this is evidence of more sophisticated behaviour to its implementation of knowledge of medicinal plants, told Dobey. The idea that Neanderthals were a little bit simple and simply dragging their knuckles around is one that has run a long time ago, surely in the anthropological world.
Dobney believes the new approach could demonstrate valuable in understanding the evolution not only of our diet but also of our microbiota, suggesting similar analysis be carried out on the remains of even earlier hominid relatives. We can really start to mine this amazing record of our joint evolutionary history with these key microorganisms that are basically part of our lives and keep us alive, he said.
Chris Stringer, a palaeoanthropologist and expert in human origins from the Natural History Museum in London who was not involved in the research, greeted such studies. It is tremendous work and very exciting, he said.
But, he advises, the dental tartar might not tell the full narrative, since it might not preserve all components of a Neanderthals diet , nor the proportions in which they were eaten. Contamination from DNA preserved in sediments in the cave must also be considered, he told, while the plant material may be in meat-eating Neanderthals might, at least in part, have come from the hominids eating the stomach contents of their prey.
Stringer is also enthusiastic about the revelations around the Neanderthals microbiota. To have that data from inside the mouth of a Neanderthal from 50,000 years ago is astounding stuff, he said.
Read more: www.theguardian.com